Indian Markets At All Time Highs | Should You Buy? Or Should You Sell?

I recently shared this image on Stable Investor’s Facebook page.
Stock Market Buy Sell Low High

And to be honest, this is not the first time I am sharing this image with Facebook Fans. I have shared it more than thrice. And it is because the image is a very powerful depiction of what actually happens in our stock markets. Investors Market participants act so irrationally on just what they hear on the street that sometimes it seems market, is just one hell of an irrational place. But then this realisation occurs that it is because of this irrationality, that rational investors get an opportunity to make money in stock markets.
Just last week, markets hit a new life time high.
2008 Indian Market Crash New Highs
2008 – 2014 | Markets Reaching New Highs | But Does It Give Red Signals?

The rise this time is not as steep as it was in the run up to the crash of 2008. The PE of market at peaks of 2008 had reached almost 26!! Currently, markets are in more (not totally) rational territory of 18 to 19. But it seems that since 3 months, markets have started running ahead of their fundamentals. And if one uses a little common sense and is aware of stock markets, this can be cross checked with views floating in the market. Almost all experts of stock markets are coming out with buy calls and asking investors to go ahead and invest in currently rising market. And many are planning to ride this run up to the elections.
But a little rational thinking would make one realise that one should buy when prices are low, and not the other way round. Even the master investor Warren Buffet has said
And as of now, people intend to make quick money in the markets and are being greedy (to a degree).
But there is another interesting indicator which somewhat refutes the above stance. I just did a comparison of returns in last 5 years with that of returns in next 5 years. It was a simple exercise to see whether there exists a correlation between what has happened in last 5 years with what is about to happen in next 5 years.
And results of the analysis of 3614 data points (spanning more than 14 years) boils down to the following table –

Stock Market Returns 5 Years
Currently, Indian markets have given a return of almost 4.5% in last five years. This puts us in the second cell of table above; which translates into an average return of almost 14% in next five years. So does it mean that Sensex, which today stands at 21,919 would reach more than 42,000* by 2019??
* (Logic: This calculation is based on concept of compound annual growth rate. In this case, an average increase of 14% every year for next five years would take Sensex from 21919 to 42000)
I know you are thinking that this guy refutes anyone giving out predictions about future levels of Sensex. And here he himself is throwing numbers like 42,000 for Sensex in next 5 years!!
But please realise that this not me. It is the past that is speaking. And one cannot just depend on past data to predict future. So take the above numbers with a pinch of salt. Anyways, data is one thing and using this data another. So what should a sensible market-fearing investor do at this moment?
Since everyone is eager to buy, a sensible person would be better off not-buying. And if it means that you might just miss the next bull run, then so be it. It is always better to control the downside before worrying about the upside in stock markets. (My thoughts || You are more than welcome to differ) 🙂
If you have your SIPs in good mutual funds, then do not stop them. Just continue with them as in the long run, this stopping of SIPs might disturb the magic of compounding.  Keep accumulating money in fixed instruments to fund your next major stock buying opportunity when markets go down and everyone else is hell bent on selling everything they hold.
So, what are you going to do now? Will you buy? Will you sell? Or will you do nothing?


  1. I tend to buy those stocks which have crashed in even this market… For example NTPC dipped quite a bit (154 in December to 114 just a few days ago)… It made sense for me… Didn't bet my shirt on it, just some 8000 Rs. or so…

    My rule is to never buy more than 5000 to 10000 at a given time… I know this sounds a bit silly, but better to bet your tie first, then your shirt, then your vest and undies on a stock…. That way, margin of safety is maintained… The downside is reduced a bit due to this, which is always my first concern.

    Also, if the stock dips more, then I buy again more confidently, as by this time I've had the time to check up on the stock a bit more thoroughly… If it goes up, too bad… There's always tomorrow, or some other stock which has crashed due to the irrational fear… In a drought, it's better to be a vulture than a proud lion…


  2. Hi Bharat, good thoughts, i too follow same thing. Here patience plays important role. I am buying IOC using this strategy since last 3 years. I have accumulated good quantity and enjoyed nice dividend. using this strategy investment becomes less riskier with time …!!!

    Happy investing…!!!

  3. Some really cool and interesting combinations of words and phrases there Bharat. 🙂
    Really loved reading your comment.
    And it makes perfect sense. Investing on bad news is one of the prime ways big investors make money.
    And the last line took it all – 'In a drought, it's better to be a vulture than a proud lion…'

  4. Good day!

    I am owner of the land have a calculated profitable business plan.Ischu investor, as in our country can be son-Russian loan from 21,3%. tell me how to act and to seek WMD? Desirable response to the post:

  5. Any idea where i can get consolidated PE from the time Nifty index was started ?… How did you get this consolidated pe ?

  6. “Interest rates are to asset prices sort of like gravity to the apple,” said Warren Buffett, “When interest rates are low there is little gravitational pull on asset prices …”
    p/e of 18 when the force of gravity is 8% is not cheaper than a market at p/e of 24 when same force is at 4%

  7. Hi.

    My 3 Core funds based on detailed analysis of SIP return and the risk reward ratio + Standard deviation are:

    1. Franklin India Prima Plus
    2. HDFC Equity
    3. Quantum Long Term Equity Fund.

    The above is based on 100% equity investment.

    If you want to have some debt also to contain volatility:

    1. Replace HDFC Equity with HDFC Prudence.
    2.Retain QLTEF since it is taking cash calls based on valuation (indirectly acts like a balanced fund).
    3. Retain Franklin Prima Plus.

Leave a Reply